On the surface, it seems like a great headline: America will pay down its debts in the current quarter, marking the first time in six years that has happened.
But the details are disturbing … and a sign that federal spending continues to be slashed right when the economy needs it most.
The U.S. Treasury said it expects to pay off $35 billion of debt in the April-to-June quarter. The main reason is because the previous projection was borrowing of $103 billion, and we need less than a third of that.
In a statement, Treasury said the debt payment was thanks to both higher receipts as well as lower “outlays,” but didn’t reveal specifics.
That’s probably because the specifics reveal a dark side to this theoretically sunny story; the idea of “lower spending and higher tax revenue” is an oversimplification.
Let me try my hand at it.
Spending has plummeted because there are about 600,000 fewer government jobs since the financial crisis, as well as deep cuts to food safety and transportation programs, among others. At the same time, higher payroll taxes mean less in the paychecks of the average consumer and more in the coffers of government.
Still sound good?
Fiscal conservatives and free-market theorists have been running with the idea of austerity and cutting federal spending since the Great Recession obliterated American budgets — from governments to businesses to regular families. But this kind of thinking simply doesn’t work.
Reinhart and Rogoff have been debunked after their debt-to-GDP paper proved to be painfully inaccurate due to a spreadsheet error. Europe is in turmoil as leaders like Enrico Letta refuse to suffer “death by austerity” and are unconvinced that gutting spending and driving up unemployment further is a viable solution. In America, cuts to air traffic controllers painfully proved how some spending is crucial to a functional economy.
I’m fine with living within our means and thinking about future spending — particularly the ticking time bomb of Social Security, entitlements and aging Baby Boomers.
But cutting spending and raising taxes just to pay our debt for paying debt’s sake — even as GDP slows to a crawl and unemployment remains persistently high — doesn’t make sense. Especially when borrowing costs are ridiculously low as the world flocks to U.S. Treasuries as the safe haven of choice.
So go ahead and cheer the debt payments if you like. Me, I’m rooting for higher spending in the short-term lest the wheels fall off this sputtering recovery.
- When you back out inventory growth, the economy is expanding at a meager 1.5% annual rate. (The Slant)
- Also: “We just have not been able to hit escape velocity, to get us growing fast enough to make up for the ground we lost during the recession.” (NYT)
- Oh and by the way: Ugly manufacturing data today shows the need for a jumpstart more than ever. (Business Insider)
Jeff Reeves is the editor of InvestorPlace.com and the author of “The Frugal Investor’s Guide to Finding Great Stocks.” Write him at email@example.com or follow him on Twitter via @JeffReevesIP.